I am running this quest right now. I have to say this task is soooo buggy and completely ruin the fun of that whole "detective "thing. My scenario was I first took the case, and consulted it to the gnome in the rabbit hole. I did exactly what the gnome suggested me to do, bought the circlet before talk to Boroquin and Rakham, and did have the fun to see how their testimony changed before and after casting the relative spell on them. I first talked to Boroquin , and he was the suspect. My party knocked him out and got the locket from him. He said the children were at the place near the church; then I talked to Rakham, he also said exactly the same thing, but the children still no where to be found. Even it seem completely unrelated, I figured probably I still need to find Panathaes to end this quest. Panathaes was so darn hard to find, he cannot be seen, only put the party member of highest spot point near by the ripple he created that he will show. Anyway I managed to take Panathaes with me. I took him to captain Abiram , and told him that Boroquin was the culprit.(since I have 6 members so I have to turn him in first to make the room for the children). Yet even with both testimony of Boroquin and Rakham, note of Panathaes and child's locket from Boroquin, the dialog option still only has "farewell" "I change my mind" when the good captain Abiram ask me how do I know it was the day steward. I also unable to turn in Panathaes, so he just stay in my party. Oh, and in that time my logbook already said I found all 3 pieces of evident. (This is also another bug, since I got this on my logbook when I only talked to two of the three guys) Not knowing what to do, I reluctantly sent one of my party member away, returned to sewer to retrieve the kids, thinking probably the good captain need to see the children alive then make a case against Boroquin. Yet as soon as I return to surface, the kids vanish, and my dialog option to captain Abiram still not changing. Now I am completely lost. The quest still marks as unfinished, and I seriously think I did anything logical to play with the "detective" thing. Please just told me what I did wrong or what flag/cheat code I should write to finish this god damn quest.