[Spoilers!] What's a full list of actions in Co8 New Content with T+ that causes a Paladin to fall?

Why doesn't someone (perhaps even OP?) compile the list? At least for the reputations? There used to be one, but since Spellslinger (and now possibly Sitra) made changes, it would be good to have an up to date one.

To make the list, either:

a) start a party with an unfallen Paladin, save, and console the reputations one at a time, see what causes falling. Reload and repeat through the first 25 or so reputations (representing the original ones, unless Sitra / Darkstorm expanded it and added more).

b) Find the dll address of the reps - 5481A - and see which are 00 and which are 01.

 

Well sure, now it does... (this is what happens when you trust information from random seven year old threads).

Well, since you've done that, I will do the other:

- if you tell Burne you know who is sabotaging the castle, but refuse to give up the name
- ditto for Rufus
- extorting gold from Gremag to keep his secrets
- ditto for Rannos
- consorting with Mary (baaaa!)
- intimidating Lodriss into carnality
- taking up Lodriss on freely offered shenanigans (Paladinate celibacy ftw)
- agreeing to assasinate Lodriss for Skole
- attacking Ikian and co (choosing the 'attack' option in dialogue)
- beggering the miller's servant (Erliter, I think?)

Or if you commit the following killings (over and above the Butcher of Hommlet rep that covers many innocents)
- Verbobonc mage
- Verbobonc guard
- Gnome guard
- Canon Thaddeus ("Canon, you're fired!")
- the Overseer
- Prince Zook
- Canon Ramses
- Jenna
- Lady Asherah
- Pelor Cleric
- Jewel Merchant
- Capt Absalom
- the Viscount
- Elysia
- the Proprietor
- Boroquin
- Rakham

 

Lareth is a Chaotic Evil agent of the Temple of Elemental Evil - who historically performed atrocities in the region to the extent that Prince Thrommel, a high level Paladin led a mighty army against the Temple's army at Emridy Meadows. With the aid of the Circle of Eight - a legendary group comprised of the most powerful Wizards in the world, managed to defeat them and seal up the Temple so no Evil could escape from within it.

Lareth was found to be actively working towards restoring the Temple to it's former glory, a crime I'm sure any Paladin would struggle to allow to go unanswered for. Since Paladins themselves would fall from grace for dishing out unjust punishment, the very fact they haven't fallen is proof enough that the punishment was rightfully deserved... though an option to knock him out and haul his ass to jail instead might be a nice twist.

 

Well, all it does is give you rep 25, which Sitra did not idenfity above as a makes-you-fall rep, so perhaps this is somehow a Temple+ thing. Certainly I can't see anything else in Grud's dlg or py files that would cause it.

This is a known broken thing, we reworked it in KotB by adding a Holy Symbol to perform a (working) Detect Evil effect. Not sure if anything was done with ToEE. Apparently not!