I would like to change the cutlass to be: considered a shortsword (finessable, use wpn fcs shortsword, etc.) 1d6 slashing damage 20 x2 critical threat range and multiplier (seems fair because slashing is more effective in ToEE) I would also like to change Excalibur back to a medium longsword, so it would be: +5 enhancement bonus medium (one-handed for medium creatures) 1d8 slashing damage holy Since a player can't craft onto Excalibur without having the +5 enhancement replaced by a +3, I wouldn't be adverse to making it Keen as well. Also, although I know very little of Greyhawk, I would like to see it become more in-line with the Holy Avenger I know and love. How about a once/day cast Dispel Magic? I know someone changed Excalibur from looking at the protos inside the DATs. I don't see any mention of it in the 5.0.0 release notes, and don't want to step on any toes, but I (and others) love this game because it's the most rules-compliant. That's what Troika and most of the modders were/are trying for, so I would like to de-munchkin some of these weapons... when possible. Feedback? Any other suggestions? P.S. The cutlass doesn't appear in the weapon tables of the Hypertext d20 SRD, if anyone out there has a 3.5e PHB or DMG or other source where it does appear I would gladly use those stats instead. Also, some debate on the cutlass issue can be found here and here.